The Extra Mile

Partnerships between hedge funds and investors

AIMA STEERING COMMITTEE WITH BARCLAYS CAPITAL SOLUTIONS

I am delighted to introduce, on behalf of the AIMA (the Alternative Investment Management Association) Investor Steering Committee, our new paper, The Extra Mile: Partnerships between Hedge Funds and Investors, written in conjunction with Barclays Capital Solutions. The paper is based on a survey of major hedge fund investors and hedge fund managers with a combined $2.2 trillion in assets.

The publication of the paper comes at an important time in the evolution of the hedge fund industry globally. Amid the ongoing process of institutionalisation (a theme that we first addressed in AIMA’s Roadmap to Hedge Funds in 2008), institutional investors are actively pursuing a more direct engagement with the underlying hedge funds in which they are invested.

The paper explores the changing relationships between hedge fund managers and investors. What we have found is that investors are increasingly striking up partnerships with hedge funds. These partnerships take many forms, including the sharing of knowledge on expertise and risk management, the building of more customised products, co-investment solutions, product seeding and equity investment. As the title of the paper implies, both parties are properly investing in these relationships – they are going the extra mile – and, in doing so, are achieving significant benefits for both sides.

I would like to express our sincerest gratitude to Barclays for collaborating with the AIMA Investor Steering Committee (ISC) on the project. I would also like to thank AIMA on behalf of the ISC for their continued commitment to investor engagement, which is so widespread today. The ISC has been responsible for a number of publications in recent years including ‘Beyond 60/40: the evolving role of hedge funds in institutional investor portfolios’,[1] the ‘Roadmap to Hedge Funds’[2], the world’s first educational guide for institutional investors in hedge funds, and the ‘Guide to Institutional Investors’ Views and Preferences’[3], which discusses a variety of important operational and organisational issues. A final word of thanks is due to my fellow investors for devoting so much of their time to this initiative.

I hope that you enjoy the paper and find it to be as useful a reference tool as those earlier ISC publications.

Michelle McGregor-Smith
Chair, AIMA Investor Steering Committee
Chief Executive, British Airways Pension Investment Management Ltd

________________________________________________________

Study overview
As the hedge fund industry evolves and becomes increasingly institutional, many hedge funds are reorienting their business models away from the idea of selling a fixed product offering, and instead toward the principle of becoming partners, using their expertise to deliver solutions for investors.

In this piece, undertaken in conjunction with the AIMA Investor Steering Committee, we explore the development of this new trend, looking at the rationale for the development of these partnerships, what they consist of, and how managers looking to get involved in partnerships should think about them.
The main areas we address are the following:

1. Partnership rationale
a. What have been the factors driving recent growing interest in partnerships?
b. What are the benefits to hedge fund managers and investors in forming partnerships?

2. Elements of partnerships
a. What are the typical elements of partnerships between hedge funds and investors?
b. What defines each element, and how do they work?
c. How prevalent are these elements relative to each other?

3. Attributes of partners
a. What criteria do investors use to select hedge fund managers as partners?
b. Are hedge funds of a certain size or strategy more attractive?
c. Are fee concessions essential in the context of partnerships?

4. Key considerations for hedge funds
a. How should hedge fund managers think about partnerships in the context of their strategy? Are certain types of partnerships more or less attractive?
b. How should hedge funds select investors to target for building partnerships?
c. What lessons can hedge funds learn from funds of hedgefunds (FoHFs)?

Methodology
With these areas in mind, Barclays Strategic Consulting team tapped three sources to gather the required information for the study:

1. Investors
– A total of 30 investors were surveyed, including a number of members of AIMA’s Investor Steering Committee.
– These investors manage over $2 trillion of overall AUM and over $260 billion of AUM invested in hedge funds.

2. Managers
– Interviewed 21 managers, including several that have been at the forefront of developing the concept of partnership with investors.
– Focused on established managers, across a range of strategies and sizes.

3. Hedge fund industry databases
– Over 10,000 data points analysed from HFR, BarclayHedge, and HFN.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The following are high-level takeaways from the study:

Partnership rationale

  • Partnerships present significant benefits for investors and managers alike.
  • Hedge fund investors have become increasingly sophisticated in their view of their hedge fund investments, looking at hedge funds as a way to tailor the risk/return profile of their entire portfolio and, simultaneously, they have concentrated their hedge fund portfolios to a smaller number of managers. As such, they are looking to have fewer but more meaningful relationships with hedge funds to obtain the following benefits:
  1. Access to hedge fund expertise/skills: partner investors can leverage hedge funds’ knowledge and expertise.
  2. Customisation: partner investors can work with hedge funds to develop customised solutions for their investment needs.
  3. Increased understanding: partner investors are likely to have greater knowledge and understanding of the managers they are partnered with.
  4. Value for money: partner investors say they can obtain more value from their hedge fund investments, often for the same or sometimes lower fees.
  • Managers have five main reasons for forming partnerships with investors:
  1. ‘Stickier’ tickets: partner investors are more likely to be loyal investors and allocations to partner hedge funds are generally for the longer term.
  2. New product development: partner investors can help launch new products by providing seed capital or being early investors.
  3. Cross-selling opportunities: partner investors may be more open to investing in the manager’s other products.
  4. Knowledge sharing: hedge funds can learn from investors – e.g., a pension fund partner can be helpful in showing hedge funds how to interact with pensions and to cater better to their needs.
  5. Investor references: investors can act as a positive reference to fellow investors.

Elements of partnership

  • Investors and managers cite six key elements they value in partnerships: highly responsive and proactive client service, knowledge sharing, customisation, co-investments, product seeding and equity stakes.
  • A highly responsive and proactive client service is a prerequisite to form a partnership with hedge funds, but partnerships have to be based on much more than that.
  • Knowledge sharing comes in different flavours, each having different cost and scalability characteristics, as well as appeal to investors. No matter what form such knowledge sharing takes, the objective of hedge fund managers is to demonstrate to investors they are the ‘go-to’ on their specific areas of expertise.
  • Customisation is often at the core of what partnership is for most hedge fund investors. As investors are becoming more sophisticated, they are utilising customised mandates to tailor their investments and risk exposures to suit their own preferences.
  • Co-investments are an important way in which hedge funds and investors partner on opportunistic investments, many of which do not fit neatly into a commingled fund vehicle.
  • Equity stakes represent a full alignment of interest and allow investors to share in the economics of hedge fund management companies; however, they also present drawbacks and therefore only a few investors and managers choose to take this route.

Attributes of partners

  • Investors care about both the right set of capabilities as well as the right attitude toward investors in the hedge fund managers they decide to partner with.
  • In terms of capabilities, larger hedge fund firms with broad strategies are most often described as good partners, although smaller managers with narrower strategies also have a role to play and are, indeed, preferred by some investors.
  • Investors typically value hedge funds which are ‘solutions-oriented’ and transparent above all else when they have to choose a partner.
  • Investors are divided as to whether fee concessions are a necessary part of partnership, with half stating they are an integral part of what partnerships are and the remainder saying that partnerships are not about fees.

Key considerations for hedge funds

  • Hedge funds’ strategy-related characteristics have a role to play in determining the types of partnerships that make the most sense for them.
  • Partnerships require time and effort, so hedge fund managers must choose the investors they partner with carefully. Choice is a function of the size of an investor and their appetite for various elements of partnership.
  • Hedge funds can learn from the successful funds of hedge funds (FoHFs) that have reoriented themselves from being product-oriented businesses toward a solutions-based model.
  • Some hedge fund managers have made the decision not to seek partnerships for a variety of reasons, suggesting that this too could be a viable strategy in the right circumstances.

Conclusions
The growth of partnerships between hedge fund managers and investors represents an exciting new direction for the hedge fund industry as it continues to evolve. Investors should certainly take advantage of the openness of the majority of hedge funds to work with them to find the right solutions for their investment needs.

It might require that some investors break down the silos between traditional investments and hedge funds or alternatives: this is not always easy to do but is worthwhile, according to the vast majority of the investors we interviewed.

For managers for whom this new direction represents an interesting concept, we would conclude with the following key take-aways:

1. There are multiple reasons why both hedge fund managers and large investors are increasingly seeking partnerships with each other; both stand to benefit from a closer relationship.

2. Not all hedge fund managers can or should seek partnerships – based on size, capability set/approach, and strategy, some hedge funds may be better off just focusing on making their product a success.

3. Consider putting in place a strategy if you decide that you do want to pursue partnerships with select investors, i.e., decide what form your partnerships should take in advance and plan accordingly:

– What elements of partnership do you want to offer and why do you think you are well positioned to be successful?
– Where is investment required within your firm to deliver on these elements?
– Which investors do you plan to target and what are the criteria you used to come up with this list?

4. Partnership is more than just client service, but enhanced client service is the first step – managers seeking to pursue partnerships need to:

– Hire high-quality individuals in the client service area who have strong product expertise.
– Structure organisations and client service teams to be able to deliver on the partnership value proposition.

5. Don’t try to be all things to all people – one of the key risks of partnerships is that a manager tries to cater to the disparate needs of more than a handful of investors; this can be a distraction and hurt the business in the long run.

6. Choose your partners carefully – the best partners aren’t necessarily the biggest; managers also need to consider which investors are likely to make the best long-term collaborators, not potential competitors down the road.

Notes

[1] http://www.aima.org/download.cfm/docid/77A589A0-3BEA-4559-B0F0EE38CF21B1CF
[2] http://www.aima.org/en/education/aimas-roadmap-to-hedge-funds.cfm
[3] http://www.aima.org/download.cfm/docid/CF822EF3-CB7A-4B13-81A7949E4C97C0AA